This 200-page report is the fruit of a year’s work by a team of 5 teacher-researchers and the Institute’s sustainable development manager. Accompanied by a 15-page summary, it is based on more than 200 scientific publications and the latest reports from institutions in the aeronautical sector. The researchers have supplemented this reference framework by integrating research results specific to ISAE-SUPAERO. The entire document has undergone a rigorous review process, both internally and by recognised scientific experts in the aviation sector, climatology, energy, etc.
The writing of this reference report was motivated by questions relating to the impact of aviation on the climate. Is it possible to characterise the impact of aviation on the climate? Can we compare CO2 and non-CO2 effects? What are the technological solutions and avenues for innovation linked to aviation and the climate? Can we link the rate of growth in air traffic to the proportion of the carbon budget devoted to aviation? Can we assess the energy resources available?
A collaborative tool
The aim of this work is not to take sides or to provide answers to the various questions raised, as the answers depend largely on societal choices and techno-economic developments that are impossible to predict with any certainty.
On the other hand, the aim is to provide everyone, on the basis of scientists’ positions, with the information they need to form informed opinions on these issues, as objectively as possible. The scientists hope to stimulate debate and thus contribute to the emergence of a collective position on these crucial issues.
This reference guide sets out the state of the art of the various levers that the aviation sector can use to reduce its environmental impact.
Key messages for low-carbon aviation
The purpose of the ISAE-SUPAERO Aviation and Climate Report is to provide scientific information useful for understanding aviation and climate issues. It consists of three main parts.
The first presents the impact of aviation on the climate, its CO2 and non-CO2 effects, while the second looks at the technological levers for reducing it.
Finally, illustrative transition scenarios for the aviation sector are proposed in the last section. This is based in particular on CAST (AEROmaps), an innovative modelling tool developed at ISAE-SUPAERO and available as a web application, which can be used to assess the climate impact of aviation as a function of variables such as traffic volume, the pace of technological change and the rate of decarbonisation of the fuel used.
- The climate impact of aviation: estimates that depend on the scope of the study
Aviation contributes to global warming through its CO2 emissions and a number of non-CO2 effects such as condensation trails. The assessment of the impact of the aviation sector can be limited to CO2 emissions alone, or it can take into account all the effects. In the first case, commercial aviation was responsible for 2.6% of global anthropogenic CO2 emissions in 2018. If all effects are considered (CO2 and non-CO2), commercial aviation accounted for 5.1% of the climate impact over the period 2000-2018.
- Non-CO2 effects: promising strategies
Specific strategies to reduce non-CO2 effects represent a major lever for limiting the climate impact of aviation. Because of the short lifespan of non-CO2 effects, these strategies can be effective very quickly. Even if more research is needed to reduce uncertainties, these strategies could be deployed in the short term. Nevertheless, these measures cannot replace efforts to reduce the sector’s CO2 emissions.
- CO2 effects: technological opportunities limited in the short term
Between now and 2050, breakthrough solutions offer the prospect of a low-carbon aircraft. In the shorter term, the only mature levers for reducing CO2 emissions within the timeframe set by the climate emergency are incremental improvements in aircraft efficiency and the use of biofuels. However, incremental improvements are on the verge of reaching their technological limits, while the constraints of energy availability, production capacity and competition over uses are likely to limit the availability of biofuels.
- A necessary trade-off between traffic levels and the share of the global carbon budget allocated to the aviation sector
Apart from technological and operational levers, the level of traffic and the share of the global carbon budget allocated to aviation are the two parameters that determine the sustainability of a trajectory for the aviation sector. Their value must be set by political decisions. The limits on the aviation sector’s ability to rapidly reduce its CO2 emissions imply that, if traffic grows at the rate envisaged by the aviation industry, it will consume a larger share of the carbon budget than its current share of emissions, thus requiring other sectors of activity to reduce their emissions faster than the average.
- Uncertainties over energy availability
The decarbonisation of aviation fuels could be limited by the availability of low-carbon energy resources. Their massive use could then lead to a displacement of environmental problems, particularly related to land use. Generally speaking, it is necessary to consider the transition of the aviation sector in a systemic way within the framework of planetary limits.
Evolving strategies
Several conclusions can be drawn from this benchmark. In particular, it reveals that the formation of clouds by aircraft condensation trails currently has a greater effect on global warming than their CO2 emissions. However, it seems possible to radically reduce these condensation trails by modifying the trajectories of a small proportion of flights: this subject, which has not yet been studied in depth, needs to be investigated as soon as possible. There are technical solutions and avenues of innovation for aviation and the climate that would make it possible to significantly reduce CO2 emissions by further improving aircraft fuel efficiency and switching to low-carbon fuels. However, it will take several decades to develop, industrialise and deploy these solutions across the entire fleet.
Based on possible scenarios between now and 2050, the report highlights the relationship between the level of air traffic in the coming decades and the share of the global carbon budget allocated to aviation. This document is aimed at players in the aviation sector, to help them define their decarbonisation strategies, while contributing to the public debate by providing the most objective possible insight into a subject that is as complex as it is important.
Standards and summary of standards :
Photo of the team of 6 authors from ISAE-SUPAERO: 5 teachers-researchers and the sustainable development manager
Related Content
News
The SOLAR BOOST project helps address the problem of urban transportDecarbonization
Sustainability
Pages
Languages, Arts, Cultures, and Societies Department (LACS)At the Languages, Arts, Cultures, and Societies Department (LACS), we teach languages, interculturality, geopolitics, general culture, economics, sports, etc. Multidimensional skills that bring out knowledge, interpersonal skills, know-how and interpersonal skills.
LACS
PhD
Researcher
Pages
Aerodynamics, Energetics, and Propulsion Department (DAEP)At ISAE SUPAERO, the Aerodynamics, Energetics, and Propulsion Department has a staff of 62, 30 research projects including 5 on a European scale, an exceptional fleet of test facilities for teaching and research purposes, and three research groups contributing to a growth strategy focused on 4 themes of current scientific and social-economic challenge, supported by 2 structuring projects: the SAA wind tunnel and the IC3 large-scale simulation code.
DAEP
PhD
Researcher
News
Our alumni have their say: Meeting with Nathanaël Lecompte (S2021)Nathanaël is a recent graduate of ISAE-SUPAERO with a degree in engineering. Of all the opportunities available to him, he chose to pursue a career in renewable energy. He explains his motivations and his career path!
Sustainability
News
Our alumni have their say: Vinh Ly, co-founder of KyanosAlumni
Career
Startup
News
Corentin Lefloch, an engineering student, wins first prize at the USAIRE STUDENT AWARDS for his ideas on the future of aviationSustainability
Videos
HORIZONS, ISAE-SUPAERO's renewed sustainable development strategyAt ISAE-SUPAERO, environmental issues are at the heart of our commitment. We are therefore mobilizing our teaching skills and scientific expertise to help build the aeronautical and space components of this sustainable society, and in particular to invent the low-carbon air transport of tomorrow.
Horizons
Sustainability
Pages
Job offersAeronautics
Decarbonization
Internship
News
Decarbonised aviation: first successful flight test for the hydrogen-powered Mermoz droneIn January, the first ‘Drone Mermoz’ demonstrator carrying hydrogen gas, developed by ISAE-SUPAERO in partnership with H3 DYNAMICS, successfully completed its first radio-controlled flight on the runway of the Muret model aircraft club in the Toulouse region (31).
Decarbonization
Sustainability
News
Envision responsible air transportAeronautics
Sustainability
Pages
Design and Operation of Aerospace Vehicles Department (DCAS)At ISAE-SUPAERO, the Design and Operation of Aerospace Vehicles Department (DCAS) develops methods, simulation tools and experimental platforms for the design and operation of aerospace vehicles.
DCAS
PhD
Researcher
News
Ranking of the top schools most committed to ecological transition: ISAE-SUPAERO in 2nd place!Ranking
Sustainability
News
Nicolas Cruaud, Engineer at ISAE-SUPAERO and co-founder of the start-up NéolitheMeeting
Presentation
Startup
News
Let's make together a durable commitment to new horizonsAeronautics
Horizons
Sustainability
News
OSE L'ISAE-SUPAERO: a long-term commitmentDiversity program
Sustainability
Pages
“Design and Analysis of Critical Systems” (CASC) scientific groupThe “Design and Analysis of Critical Systems” (CASC) scientific group focuses on methods, processes and tools to support System Engineering and Systems Engineering.
DISC
Doctoral student
PhD
Pages
“Photonics Antenna Microwave PlasmaA” (PAMPA) scientific groupThe “Photonics Antenna Microwave PlasmaA” (PAMPA) scientific group is interested in electromagnetism in the fields of microwaves and photonics, as well as wave-plasma interactions.
DEOS
Doctoral student
PhD
Pages
“Space Systems for Planetology and Applications” (SSPA) scientific groupThe “Space Systems for Planetology and Applications” (SSPA) scientific group focuses on one main area of research: the development of missions and associated technologies for geophysical exploration of the solar system.
DEOS
Doctoral student
PhD
Pages
Complex Systems Engineering Department (DISC)Within ISAE-SUPAERO, the Complex Systems Engineering Department (DISC) develops skills in mathematics and computer science for aeronautical and space engineering. In both teaching and research, it focuses on the models, methods, and tools needed to control the behavior and performance of complex systems. This complexity may be induced by the multi-physics or multi-scale nature of the systems studied, their dynamic behavior, or their distributed and communicating structure.
DISC
PhD
Researcher
News
Investing and committing to training and research to meet the challenges of the energy transitionISAE-SUPAERO and the ISAE-SUPAERO Foundation work together and take their share of responsibility for addressing these major challenges facing our society. Actions include raising awareness and training future aeronautical engineers, and setting up research programmes to better address energy and climate issues.
Sustainability
News
AeroMAPS: a tool for assessing the environmental impacts of the aviation sector's transitionISAE-SUPAERO has released AeroMAPS, an open-source tool for modelling transition scenarios for the aviation sector. The result of three years of research at the Institute, it enables users to accurately assess the effectiveness of different impact reduction strategies in relation to international commitments to combat climate change.
Decarbonization
Sustainability
News
Carbon neutrality: What strategy should ISAE-SUPAERO adopt?Sustainability
News
ICAO (International Civil Aviation Organisation) Congress: Laurent Joly, Deputy Director of Research at ISAE-SUPAERO, talks about the Institute's commitmentsEvent
Sustainability
News
Our partners are going green!Sustainability
Pages
ResearchDAEP
DCAS
DEOS
Pages
“Navigation, Radar and Remonte Sensing” (NAVIR² eS) scientific groupThe “Navigation, Radar and Remonte Sensing” (NAVIR² eS) scientific group is interested in the theoretical study of information sources and hybridization approaches for autonomous vehicle navigation applications.
DEOS
Doctoral student
PhD
Pages
Lasbordes Air Operations Center (COAL)The Design and Operation of Aeronautical and Space Vehicles Department (DCAS) is part of the Lasbordes Air Operations Center (COAL), located on an airfield a few kilometers from the ISAE-SUPAERO campus. As part of its aeronautical training and research activities, COAL operates a fleet of 9 light aircraft.
DCAS
Doctoral student
PhD
Pages
DirectoryTeacher researcher
Pages
“Integrated Image Sensors” (CIMI) scientific groupThe “Integrated Image Sensors” (CIMI) scientific group, develops and characterizes active-pixel image sensors (CMOS Image Sensors (CIS)) on silicon for visible and infrared radiation.
DEOS
Doctoral student
PhD
Pages
“Communication and Information Theory” (ComiT) scientific groupThe “Communication and Information Theory” (ComiT) scientific group is involved in the disciplines of digital communications, radar, and channel access techniques. Its fields of application include space systems, civil and military aviation, terrestrial cellular networks and the Internet of Things (IoT).
DEOS
Doctoral program
Doctoral student
News
World Engineer Day 2020: a young alumni puts his engineering skills to work for the climateOn the occasion of ‘World Engineer Day 2020,’ which focuses on the theme of sustainable development, we present the profile of Maxime Efoui Hess.
Alumni
Presentation
Sustainability
Pages
“Theory, Modeling and Systems Engineering” (ThéMIS) scientific groupThe “Theory, Modeling and Systems Engineering” (ThéMIS) scientific group is dedicated to the study and development of advanced methods for the design, modeling and validation of complex systems.
DISC
Doctoral student
PhD
Pages
“Applied Mathematics” (AM) scientific groupThe “Applied Mathematics” (AM) scientific group covers a wide range of topics: stochastic processes (especially Markov processes), numerical optimization (especially multidisciplinary optimization) and parallel computing, stabilization, control and numerical solution of partial differential equations, and financial engineering.
DISC
Doctoral student
PhD
News
ISAE-SUPAERO Environmental Engineering Certificate: training engineers in the challenges of environmental and energy transitionsAeronautics
Sustainability
Pages
Scientific and research integrityISAE-SUPAERO is one of the signatories of the National Charter of Ethics for Research Professions, adopted in January 2015 by the Conference of University Presidents (CPU) and all national research organizations, and incorporated into the Institute's internal regulations.
DAEP
DCAS
DEOS
News
ISAE-SUPAERO is broadcasting the webinar "Air transport in crisis and the climate challenge: towards new paradigms" on campus!Event
Sustainability
Pages
“Connected Systems” (SysCo) scientific groupThe scientific dynamic of the “Connected Systems” (SysCo) scientific group focuses primarily on network-related issues in aerospace applications, i.e. space communications, embedded networks and certain types of connected systems.
DISC
Doctoral student
PhD
News
The Institute is involved in the ecological transition of the aerospace ecosystemMeeting
Sustainability
News
COP2 Student: ISAE-SUPAERO affirms its commitment to ecological transition by signing the Grenoble AgreementSustainability
News
ISAE-SUPAERO expands its collaboration with TU Delft on sustainable aviationDuring President Macron's state visit to the Netherlands, five agreements were signed to strengthen collaboration between the two countries in the field of science and technology. Among them, an agreement between TU Delft and France provides for close collaboration between ISAE-SUPAERO and TU Delft in the field of sustainable aviation.
Decarbonization
Partnership
Sustainability
News
The project for an unmanned, zero-emission aircraft to cross the South AtlanticInnovation
Researcher
Sustainability
News
Work on decarbonising aviation recognised by the American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics (AIAA)Paul Saves, a doctoral student at ISAE-SUPAERO/ONERA, has won the 2022 Best Paper Award from the AIAA for his work in Multidisciplinary Design Optimization (MDO).
Decarbonization
Sustainability
News
ISAE-SUPAERO ranked among the top three institutions most committed to ecological and societal transition!Ranking
Sustainability
News
ISAE-SUPAERO and ENAC are collaborating on the design of a 100% digital degree programme in English on the subject of aviation transitions!ISAE-SUPAERO and ENAC train engineers with a high level of scientific expertise, humanistic values and innovative skills to master the complex challenges of tomorrow's world in the fields of aerospace and air transport.
Decarbonization
Sustainability